Choice Organic Teas Review (2026): Is It Worth It? Best & Worst Blends

Choice's Jasmine Green is consistently the brand's best-reviewed blend, and the ingredient list explains why. It's a green tea base scented with organic jasmine blossoms, which gives a true floral aroma without the soapy, over-perfumed quality cheaper jasmine teas fall into. Jasmine greens like this are typically light, smooth, and slightly sweet, with the jasmine sitting on top of a clean grassy green.

It carries the full credential stack, USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, and Fair Trade Certified, in a compostable bag. For roughly grocery-aisle money, this is one of the best everyday jasmine greens you can buy bagged. If you only try one Choice blend, make it this one. Check current price on Amazon.

Choice's Peppermint is the kind of single-note herbal that's easy to get wrong and they get right. It's just organic peppermint leaf, no lemongrass filler, no 'natural flavors', so the cup is bright, cooling, and genuinely minty rather than thin and hay-like.

USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, and packed in an unbleached compostable bag. At everyday prices, this is one of the best bagged peppermints on the shelf, a no-brainer pantry staple. Check current price on Amazon.

Choice's Earl Grey is the brand's most popular black tea and a dependable daily cup. It's an organic black base scented with organic bergamot oil, giving a clean citrus-floral lift that's balanced rather than aggressive. It brews into a medium-bodied cup that holds up to a splash of milk.

It's USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, and Fair Trade Certified, which is more than most supermarket Earl Greys can say. Note that Choice also sells an Earl Grey with Lavender variant if you want a more floral, perfumed take. The standard Earl Grey is the safe, versatile choice. Check current price on Amazon.

If you want a plain green tea without jasmine or mint, this is Choice's answer. Japanese-style greens like the Premium Japanese Green are typically smooth and gently grassy, with a soft finish and none of the astringent bite that plagues cheaper bagged greens. It's the kind of tea you can drink all day.

It's USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified in a compostable bag, and at multipack pricing it's genuinely cheap per cup. A solid, no-drama everyday green. Check current price on Amazon.

Choice's Chamomile is straightforward in the best way: organic chamomile flowers, nothing else. Chamomile flowers like these typically brew a soft, lightly honeyed, floral cup, fuller than the dusty, hay-flavored chamomiles often found in bargain boxes.

USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified, compostable bag. It's not the most intense chamomile out there, but it's clean, pleasant, and well-priced. Check current price on Amazon.

Oolong is the hardest style to do justice in a tea bag, and Choice's Oolong is a respectable attempt. It's light-to-medium bodied, mildly toasty, and smoother than a black tea, a friendly introduction for anyone curious about the category.

It carries USDA Organic, Non-GMO, and Fair Trade credentials, which is genuinely hard to find in an affordable bagged oolong. That said, this is the blend where the bag format shows its limits, the layered floral-and-roast character of good loose oolong is muted here. Check current price on Amazon.

Choice's Rooibos is a strong pick for anyone who wants the body of a black tea without the caffeine. The South African red bush brews a deep amber cup that's naturally sweet, nutty, and lightly woody, with no tannic bitterness no matter how long it steeps.

It's USDA Organic, Non-GMO, and Fair Trade Certified. If you're cutting caffeine but miss a robust, satisfying cup, this is the blend to reach for. Check current price on Amazon.