Stash Tea Review (2026): Is It Worth It? Best & Worst Blends

If you only try one Stash blend, make it this one. Double Bergamot Earl Grey uses roughly twice the bergamot oil of a standard Earl Grey, and the difference is immediately obvious in the cup: a brighter, more floral citrus lift over a sturdy black base. It brews dark and holds its own against a splash of milk without the bergamot disappearing.

It's a full-caffeine black tea, so treat it as a morning cup. The base leaf is solid bagged-tea quality — not a single-origin showpiece, but well above budget brands. At under a quarter per cup, it's our top value pick across the entire lineup. Buy it on Amazon.

Chai Spice blends a black tea base with cinnamon, ginger, cardamom, clove and pepper for a rounded, comforting cup. It's spice-forward but not hot, which makes it approachable for people who find some chais too peppery. Steam some milk into it and it becomes a legitimately good homemade chai latte for a fraction of a café price.

Out of the box it's a touch sweeter-smelling than it tastes, so don't be put off by the aroma. The cardamom and clove come through best with a slightly longer 4-5 minute steep. Find it on Amazon.

Premium Peppermint is exactly what it should be: clean, bright peppermint with a cooling finish and zero bitterness. It's naturally caffeine-free, which makes it an easy evening choice, and it's the blend we'd hand someone who says they 'don't like tea' — it tastes fresh rather than grassy.

One note: it's single-note by design. If you want complexity, this isn't it — but for a reliable, refreshing caffeine-free cup, it's hard to beat at the price. Buy on Amazon.

Stash's standard Earl Grey is a competent, balanced cup — restrained bergamot over a clean black base, exactly what most people picture when they think Earl Grey. It's a fine everyday choice and milks up nicely.

There's nothing wrong here; it's just that the brand makes a better version. Worth buying if you find the Double Bergamot too intense. On Amazon.

Mango Passionfruit pairs tart passionfruit and juicy mango with hibiscus and orange peel for a bright, sunny, caffeine-free cup. It's naturally sweet-tasting without added sugar, and the hibiscus gives it a gorgeous red color that makes it the standout iced tea in Stash's range.

It leans fruity-sweet in aroma, so it's not for someone who wants an austere, leafy herbal. But as a crowd-pleaser it's the easiest Stash herbal to recommend. Find it on Amazon.

Lemon Ginger delivers genuine ginger warmth with a bright lemon-lemongrass lift. It's the blend many drinkers keep on hand for cold-weather and under-the-weather days. Caffeine-free, lightly spicy, and comforting.

The ginger is present without being harsh; add honey and it's a cozy night-time cup. A dependable wellness-style herbal. On Amazon.

Moroccan Mint blends a China green tea base with spearmint, peppermint and lemongrass for a fragrant, refreshing cup that's hard to over-brew into bitterness — the mint smooths everything out. It's the green tea we'd recommend over Stash's plain Premium Green.

Lower in caffeine than the black teas, it's a good mid-day option. Lovely iced, too. Find it on Amazon.

Stash's plain Premium Green is where the brand's bagged-tea ceiling shows. It's a clean, mild green with light caffeine, but it's the most ordinary blend we tested and the least tolerant of a long steep — push past three minutes and it gets astringent.

It's not bad, and at the price it's a fine pantry green. But it's the one product here we'd steer most people away from in favor of Moroccan Mint or a loose-leaf option. On Amazon.